With classic antipasti Italian dishes, stone-baked kiawe-fired oven pizzas, and juicy Maui-raised steaks, it's hard to go wrong at this longtime Upcountry favorite. Casanova doubles as an entertainment venue, with happening live music or a nightclub on Wednesday, Friday and Saturday (10pm to 1am). Wednesday is Ladies' Night, when women get in free ($10 cover for men).
For a casual lunch, try one of the hearty sandwiches at the attached deli. There's another branch of the restaurant in Kahului.